Windows XP - my mini-review

Status
Not open for further replies.

David Geesaman

Usenet Archive
Joined
Feb 13, 2001
Messages
631
Reaction score
0
I recently got my hands on a copy of Windows XP Professional. I tested Pro/E on it and got familiar with the OS itself, and figured some here may want to read of it.
Bench system: AMD Athlon 1400MHz, Elsa GLADIAC 32MB (GeForce2), 1024MB DDR RAM, Quantum Typhoon 36.4 GB Ultra160 SCSI hard drive, fixed 500MB swap file. No swapping noted.

Pro/ENGINEER performance: nearly identical. My runs of Pro/E the Benchmark, SpecAPC were identical within a second, and OCUS (Large) was a few seconds slower, but less than a percent different. This is what I expected - XP performance should be about the same, since it's still just the NT kernel, and the nVidia drivers are unified across all platforms. Image quality, again was identical based on my quick testing, but YMMV if your graphics card has separately developed drivers for XP. The Home edition and Professional edition are now unified, which means those Win95/98 issues will slowly disappear. For home users, there is no need to buy/dual boot with NT anymore.

XP interface: it's not practical out of the box, IMO. Big, rounded icons on the default picture background are hard to read, and I'm not sure I see the improvements brought forth by the 'new' start menu. I was able to disable these changes and use the standard Win2000 interface with just a few changes in settings, and I have a feeling this is what CAD users will want to do. After all, the new interface is geared toward 'My Music', 'My Documents', and 'Network Places', which many advanced users skip completely. Additionally, network admins will want to disable it to minimize grumbles following an upgrade and keep performance up. The login screen supports picture icons for each user, so that you pick your name from the list and type only the password - much like SGI Irix does.

Resource usage: CPU usage is the same, since the benchmark scores haven't changed. RAM use on a bare installation of XP Pro is 100MB, compared to 50MB for Win2000 and 28MB for WinNT 4.0. If you push the
1.7GB barrier, this is a concern. Hard drive use is around 1GB, but will certainly grow as programs are added, compared to 300-500MB for Win2000 and 100-200MB for WinNT 4.0. Fortunately, hard drives are growing at a faster pace.

Features: I haven't had much chance to dig in here yet, but some things are very cool.
- support for zip files (no Winzip shareware nags woohoo!)
- support for burning CDs
- built-in network monitoring in Task Manager
- Remote desktop sharing (like Netmeeting or PC Anywhere). I haven't tested whether it causes any conflicts with Pro/E.
 
My favorite new feature of XP is multiple desktops (similar to the HP unix boxes). In order to get this feature you have to get the free power tools download from Microsoft. Then you can run Pro/E on one desktop, e-mail on another, PDM on another, and AutoCad on another. It's very nice except that switching windows to other desktops isn't as easy as with HP.

David Geesaman wrote:
I recently got my hands on a copy of Windows XP Professional. I tested Pro/E on it and got familiar with the OS itself, and figured some here may want to read of it.
Bench system: AMD Athlon 1400MHz, Elsa GLADIAC 32MB (GeForce2), 1024MB DDR RAM, Quantum Typhoon 36.4 GB Ultra160 SCSI hard drive, fixed 500MB swap file. No swapping noted.

Pro/ENGINEER performance: nearly identical. My runs of Pro/E the Benchmark, SpecAPC were identical within a second, and OCUS (Large) was a few seconds slower, but less than a percent different. This is what I expected - XP performance should be about the same, since it's still just the NT kernel, and the nVidia drivers are unified across all platforms.
...
 
Ahhh - I enjoy this multi windowed feature on Sun Solaris via CDE. SO the question of the day is.... when you lauch an app and quickly switch windows... does the app come up where you launched it or where you are when it gets around to coming up. I would argue that it should come up from where you kicked it off and Sun seems to think otherwise.

I've also found that more than two windows is a distraction and you end up switching windows looking for where did I put that app, unless you are incredibly disciplined or only run a few apps. I got down to two and it's much better. If it's not in one... it's in the other.

What do you mean it's not as easy to switch? don't they just have a button for each window? Maybe I have it better than I think.
-Dan

alles_eng wrote:

My favorite new feature of XP is multiple desktops (similar to the HP unix boxes). In order to get this feature you have to get the free power tools download from Microsoft. Then you can run Pro/E on one desktop, e-mail on another, PDM on another, and AutoCad on another. It's very nice except that switching windows to other desktops isn't as easy as with HP.

David Geesaman wrote:
> I recently got my hands on a copy of Windows XP Professional. I
> tested Pro/E on it and got familiar with the OS itself, and figured some
> here may want to read of it.
> Bench system: AMD Athlon 1400MHz, Elsa GLADIAC 32MB (GeForce2), ...
 
It's very easy to switch between desktops. There are four number buttons down by the system tray and you just click them. There is also a tile button which shows all four at once. You can also set hot keys to switch in between.

What is difficult is to switch a window from one desktop to another. You have to right click the taskbar, set it to shared desktops (all apps show on all desktops) then switch to the desktop you want the window in, click in the window to make it active and then right click the taskbar again and unselect shared desktops. This is disappointing, I was hoping to be able to right click the window border and then just send it to another desktop.

When I was on the HP boxes, I named the desktops names like Pro/E, PDM, E-mail, etc and then got in the habit of keeping the appropriat programs on their desktops. It worked great and I didn't have to keep minimizing/maximizing everthing all the time. In XP you can't rename the desktops, you just get 1-4.

DanB wrote:
Ahhh - I enjoy this multi windowed feature on Sun Solaris via CDE. SO the question of the day is.... when you lauch an app and quickly switch windows... does the app come up where you launched it or where you are when it gets around to coming up. I would argue that it should come up from where you kicked it off and Sun seems to think otherwise.

I've also found that more than two windows is a distraction and you end up switching windows looking for where did I put that app, unless you are incredibly disciplined or only run a few apps. I got down to two and it's much better. If it's not in one... it's in the other.

What do you mean it's not as easy to switch? don't they just have a button for each window? Maybe I have it better than I think.
-Dan
 
The 'Desks Overview' found in IRIX is spectacular (see this pic http://math.smith.edu/~vvouille/357b/desk.gif), it took MS 10 years to add a nice little feature like this to their OS? The nice thing about 'Desks Overview' is that it shows a small snapshot of each desktop (you can name each one) with window titles so you can see what is what. There is also a global desktop, anything placed on it shows up in all other desktops. To move an app between desks all you have to do is drag it. To switch to another desk just click. It also changes the color of the wallpaper/windows for each desktop so it is easier to distinguish desktops.

For anyone using NT/98/95 here is a link to a great little program called DeskWin that is the closest thing to IRIX's 'Desks Overview' that I could find:

http://download.cnet.com/downloads/0-1461990-100-5382549.html?tag=st.dl.1000 1-103-1.lst-7-1.5382549

It does act a little strange in 98 but not too bad. I often run multiple sessions of Pro/ENGINEER so having extra desks to sort everything out is great.

Later,
Chris

"alles_eng" wrote:

It's very easy to switch between desktops. There are four number buttons down by the system tray and you just click them. There is also a tile button which shows all four at once. You can also set hot keys to switch in between.

What is difficult is to switch a window from one desktop to another. You have to right click the taskbar, set it to shared desktops (all apps show on all desktops) then switch to the desktop you want the window in, click in the window to make it active and then right click the taskbar again and unselect shared desktops. This is disappointing, I was hoping to be able to right click the window border and then just send it to another desktop.
...
...
> Ahhh - I enjoy this multi windowed feature on Sun Solaris via CDE. SO
the question of the day is.... when you lauch an app
> and quickly switch windows... does the app come up where you launched it
or where you are when it gets around to coming up.
> I would argue that it should come up from where you kicked it off and
Sun seems to think otherwise.
>
> I've also found that more than two windows is a distraction and you end
up switching windows looking for where did I put
> that app, unless you are incredibly disciplined or only run a few apps.
I got down to two and it's much better. If it's not
> in one... it's in the other.
>
> What do you mean it's not as easy to switch? don't they just have a
button for each window? Maybe I have it better than I
> think.
> -Dan
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest threads

Back
Top