Wildfire users that used to use SoliWorks

Discussion in 'Pro/Engineer & Creo Elements/Pro' started by Rob Rodriguez, Jul 28, 2004.

  1. First off, my intent here is to gather opinions of past SW to Wildfire
    converts. I'm not saying one software is better than the other. I'd just
    like to hear comments on peoples experiences.

    I've been a SolidWorks user for about 6 years and REALLY know the software
    well. I have an opportunity to work for a company that is using Pro-E
    Wildfire. I'm really interested in the job but one of the things holding me
    back is not knowing Wildfire. I have a demo of Wildfire 2 and have been
    going through tutorials for about a week. I have to say that compared to SW
    Wildfire just seems so non user friendly. I thought this was just a factor
    of being new to the software but the more I use it the more I find it's not
    a comfortable interface (for me anyway). I hate to say I wouldn't take the
    position based on my demo experience with Wildfire but I'm also don't want
    to go to work everyday with a love-hate relationship with the software
    (which is what I'm developing, more hate than love) So I would like to hear
    comments from others who have made the switch. How long did it take to get
    comfortable with the software? Are you sorry you made the switch? Are you
    glad you made the switch? Anything you can tell me about your experience
    would be helpful.

    Thanks in advance.
     
    Rob Rodriguez, Jul 28, 2004
    #1
  2. Rob Rodriguez

    Jeff Howard Guest

    My two cents worth:

    It probably wouldn't qualify as being as "friendly" in most
    peoples' opinion, though the delta converges and switches if
    you were pushing SW to the ragged edge. It's mostly
    mindset. Learn the software, appreciate it for what it does
    to your liking and, well, the software hasn't yet been made
    that will please all the people all the time. I'm in a
    different boat, in that I purchased the software, so maybe
    that has something to do with the mindset. I switched from
    Inventor and it took about a month before I was comfortable
    enough that I felt no regrets, had no desire to start a
    project in IV instead of Pro.

    If you were pleased as punch with SW, you'll probably be a
    hard convert, but if you found it lacking you might come to
    like working with Pro/E.

    Do you have access to the PTC knowledge base? There is a
    slew of tutorial type "how to" articles that will help
    negotiate the learning curve. (Perhaps you can get a
    reseller to burn a bunch to CD?)
     
    Jeff Howard, Jul 28, 2004
    #2
  3. What will you be using WF for?

    I'm a WF user who has then dabled with SW and I agree the front end is
    easier to use [my student would love.......at first]. But its like anything
    else, once you've used it in anger for a couple of months the front end
    differences are insignificant. WF is a more powerful and versatile
    modeller.

    If you are modelling nothing more than simple blocky fabricated/engineered
    parts then it will probably always be quicker and easier in SW. You don't
    have to push the boundaries or the form very far to appreciate the superior
    modelling capabilities of WF - you'll get there with SW, but you'll probably
    get there quicker and closer to your design intent with WF.

    I think SW is an excellent piece of software, and in alot of ways it would
    make my job [teaching CAD/CAM] alot easier. But my first experience with it
    was a reasonable simple from which I had achieved very qickly with a
    variable section sweep on WF - I struggled with SW. I think it was a far
    test because I like SW.

    If you going for better job/pay/conditions then the differences
    [particularly with WF2] are not significant.

    There was an extensive comparison article by Mark Biasotti which I thought
    was very good - can't find the link to it now.

    Sean

    --


    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
    Sean Kerslake
    Dept. Design & Technology
    Loughborough University
    Loughborough
    LE11 3TU

    01509 228317
     
    Sean Kerslake, Jul 28, 2004
    #3
  4. I would be using WF for modeling cast iron and sheetmetal parts. Also
    for the cnc end of the pattern making (for the cast parts) and for
    mold making of other types of parts. I agree SW does have issues when
    it comes to complex shapes. I've achieved very nice challenging
    shapes with SW but at times it could be very fustrating. I haven't
    had enough experience with WF to try complex shapes and surfacing yet.
    Thanks for your input.

    Rob
     
    Rob Rodriguez, Jul 28, 2004
    #4
  5. That's been my opinion, too. If I can do it in SW, it is probably more
    pleasant to do so. But I can do more in Pro. That could just be a
    function of my outdated SW knowledge.

    I used SW 96~2000 and then went to a company using Pro/E 2000i2. I
    looked at it as an opportunity to extend my toolset. It's valuable to be
    able to work in either, especially if you do contract work as I do now.

    WF goes a long way towards approaching SW usability, IMO. If you think
    it's unpleasant to learn, just try a previous version! It did take me a
    while to become comfortable working in Pro, and there are still some
    things that make me miss SW. For the most part, though, I think you get
    used to whatever package you need to use so that you can get the job done.

    I wouldn't turn down a good opportunity based on the CAD system, as long
    as it's one that is capable and that won't lead you down a dead end
    career-wise. Pro/E and SW are both widely used and will likely continue
    to be, as will UG, Catia, and some others. Jobs requiring only AutoCAD
    experience are another story.

    I would be more interested to learn how they are using their system--do
    they have a PDM or at least a file management scheme, do they have and
    follow modeling guidelines, do they use top-down design (skeletons in
    Pro)--as a way to understand what kind of company they are.

    - Wallace
     
    Wallace White, Jul 28, 2004
    #5
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.