Pro-E vs. Unigraphics

Status
Not open for further replies.

mstols1

Usenet Archive
Joined
Jul 3, 2001
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
I've been a pro user for about 4 1/2 years now and I am thinking of going to a company that uses Unigraphics. They say that it is just as good as proe.

has anyone worked with proe and unigraphics, and how do they compare?
 
"mstols1" wrote:

I've been a pro user for about 4 1/2 years now and I am thinking of going
to
a company that uses Unigraphics. They say that it is just as good as proe.

has anyone worked with proe and unigraphics, and how do they compare?
It is more flexible than Pro and in most cases better. I have been on UG for 15 years and because of a corporate decision, we are switching to Pro. I have been to some training classes in 2000i2 and I am now starting a second set with 2001. They are almost down to a commodity item level as far as functionality. One introduces something new and the next version the other has it plus something else new. Around they go each trying to be better. One of the issues with Pro is that they don't use a standard Windows compliant interface, which makes finding things harder. Also the drop-down cascading menus get confusing at times. I understand that 2002 will have a whole new user interface, so we will have to relearn how to use Pro.
 
"mstols1" wrote:
I've been a pro user for about 4 1/2 years now and I am thinking of going to a company that uses Unigraphics. They say that it is just as good as proe.

has anyone worked with proe and unigraphics, and how do they compare?

Good day to you.
In my opinion, the current top 3 highend MCAD software for product design are (in alphabetical order) CATIA, Pro/Engineer and UG (IDEAS is out because it has been bought by UG people). Any good high end 3D MCAD software would not be easy to master when we consider designing a product with 3D complex surfaces. Learning to use and mastering are 2 different world. Demo is another much different world. I feel it is quite unlikely that a 15 year veteran UG user (superuser I should say) would be able to achieve same capabilty in Pro/E after switching to Pro/E less than 2 years (2000i2 is less than 2 years). I reccommend that anybody wanting to master 3D MCAD software to choose 1 of the above and stick to it for as long as the software is able to keep it's position in the top 3 league. You can be jack of all trades(read highend MCAD) but master of only one!

Best regards
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest threads

Back
Top