OT - the US is a lousy world citizen

Spain, France, and Great Britain all had their chance to f**k up the world in the last two centuries. Now it's our turn.

and if that's your metric, we're doing a damn fine job
 
Gee, I thought Palestine was a lousy world citizen for letting its people cross into anlther country for the sole purpose of killing innocent people. Ditto for Syria and Iran. I thought Sudan was a lousy world citizen for killing millions of Christians and enslaving many more? Guess slavery doesn't show up on the radar as bad citizenship.

And then there are China and Brazil. Both have CO plumes visible on satellite imagery. One is burniing down the world's biggest rainforest and the other is burning more coal without pollution devices than any other country. They don't need discussions, they need action.

And then there is the US. 11 million illegal immigrants from Mexico. Are they put in conncentration camps? NO. They are allowed to work and live along with everybody else. They get medical care and social security and education and access to churches. They are allowed to fly their own flag and have their own holidays. And they come here because they can get work that is not available in their own country. Is Mexico considered a bad world citizen because it can't get it's economy going despite years of help?

The US has a major city destroyed. The people there are taken care of, albeit a few days late. Compared with how India still hasn't helped many of the tsunami victims the US did a glowing good job. And the US government didn't disregard a whole group of people like India diregarded the dalits plight. When New Orleans was destroyed the US didn't need to ask the rest of the world for help (although some countries did send token help).

The US has cleaned up its air and water and land every bit as well as Europe has tried to. This can't be said of Russia, Ukraine, China and many other counrtries. In fact regulations are so strict in the US that we haven't built a petroleum refinery or nuclear power plant for years. And we burn a lot of home heating gas in power plants just to keep the air clean even though it means extremely high home heating bills.

The US walked out of climate change discussions because they had good reason to.

The US imprisons people like this in Europe.

http://encoderx.co.uk/id/id.php?fid=NB1 (don't watch before lunch)

Europeans only consider the prisoners rights and not those of the aid workers like Berg and others.

The US has fueled the astounding growth in both China and India at the expense of their own people's jobs. Bet that wouldn't fly in Europe.
 
It's an open USENET newsgroup. No such thing as "professional".

Ken
 
well said...
and you'll never hear any of this on CNN, CBS, CBC, Al Jazeera, NYTimes, etc etc

bill
 
Until quite recently the US did the slavery bit quite well itself and continues to cast people in the role of second rate citizens as minority groups will tell you.It is nice that they can raise a flag it is not long ago they could not sit on buses... The US is tolerant of illegal immigrants from Mexico, central and S.America for low paid work in controllable numbers which is why it wants a very long razor wire fence along its border. Every well to do white person can play the game of upward mobility then and have their own little empire with house servants.Rewarding participants with gratuitous tipping helps to sustain the illusion of generosity and benevolence and hope. OK so now you move on to India and China...where the growth has been in the making for some time not due to the US patronage.US business interests are in there boots and all because it is an opportunity for corporate pyramids to feed on not because they have any inherent interest in the people their wellbeing or their culture.Never mind the effect on the rest of the world ..This is naked self interest and preservation at work. The rapid industrialisation of these areas is at the expense of health,safety and environmental standards. This does not matter to a well trained credit oblivious consumer in the US because it is somewhere out of mind and the goods are cheap and the profits handsome for the entrepreneur.Try telling thousands of hardworking loyal clothing and auto workers how generous you are to make them redundant in favour of someone across the world.Capital maximisation leads to abandonment - it is an antisocial disease refined to extremes in America by people who think the world was made for them to define in their image.So driven is it that management will lie about balance sheets to the max for shareholder and ladder climbing approval. There are still a few Indians -not the ones who died outright- near a certain chemical works the US doesn't want to know about - how about a trail of unwanted children across the world left from US conflicts- there is a lot of dirt everywhere if you want to turn it over and really look at it with out star spangled good old boy glasses. Help was offered for New Orleans and was turned down by your President.I suspect there was a good deal of unspoken national guilt and embarrassment that spurred the eventual internal relief efforts.As far as I could tell there is a cultivated resentment of helping your neighbour for any real need mitigated by pointing out afterward in the politest way your personal contribution. The US consumes large amounts of the worlds energy per capita and could manage quite well with less and certainly has a responsibility to do something about the 25% of CO2 emissions it makes. Just because US cities got over run with smog and you decided to fix it and you stopped your toxic waste dumping under bushes doesn't mean you have done and can rest pretty now.There are 6 billion of us and we all need to do what we can irrespective of what others can manage.There are people to come after us. Why should they live in our can't be bothered mess? The US meddles everywhere 'intelligence' think tanks believe they should and eventually leaves tail down when they rub against reality and the great US dream and American way is exposed for the delusion it is outside the borders. Your President walks out when he someone opens the door for him. Give him a helping hand out of Iraq if he can't do it himself. There now I will have wound people up.... ;o) till next year... if you still talk to me that is :o)
neil
 
so i take it you are living in some prosperous socialist paradise?

bill
 
Ok I am being a little rough on you guys.
I am sure actually you are all very nice people with sincere beliefs and I mean you no personal malice however the ole USA needs to work in with the rest of the world in a better way from now on because it is a crowded place facing real limits. You have a famous president who it was said of 'he saw wrong and tried to right it' Your global friends and neighbours are saying your governments thinking is wrong and you need to right it....the tangent you are off on doesn't go where we need to go....

I sincerely hope you and yours have a nice Christmas and New Year, Bill regards neil
 
None.
I don't subscribe to any religion or politic or group but I know right and wrong and I speak out if it is important which this is. I know a lot of Americans say they have an fealty to the unassailable righteous governance of God which may be a little more accessible and you can front up to that and question and defy if you like.

People should not be afraid to challenge wrong ideas and actions. People should not be afraid to say something is a mistake and correct it. It is a small crowded world we share, old and young, rich and poor, strong and dependant. We all need to try harder to understand each other a little better now and get on as a world community with our differences. To do this we may have to give up some of our own beliefs, freedoms and possessions for a greater common good.

regards and seasons wishes
neil
 
neil said:
Until quite recently the US did the slavery bit quite well itself and continues to cast people in the role of second rate citizens as minority groups will tell you.It is nice that they can raise a flag it is not long ago they could not sit on buses...

Ahhh.....the downtrodden minority group. If it wasn't for this effect I would be speaking English as a second language and Plattdeutsch as my mother tongue. Everybody in the US was a minority once. Fact is minority is big business here. I know minoritties who live in neighborhoods where hunting rifles are not used to shoot deer and others in palatial homes. The difference is what they think a rifle is for. And slavery still exists in the US in case you hadn't noticed. There is a reason most companies now have a Human Resources department instead of a personell department.
The US is tolerant of illegal immigrants from Mexico, central and S.America for low paid work in controllable numbers which is why it wants a very long razor wire fence along its border.

Which US? Bush doesn't want the fence. A lot of others do. Good thing Bush is in or we would have another Berlin wall. Begs the question of why Mexico which has oil, education and resources can't feed her own people. Now there is a place where the rich are rich and the poor are poor.
Every well to do white person can play the game of upward mobility then and have their own little empire with house servants.Rewarding participants with gratuitous tipping helps to sustain the illusion of generosity and benevolence and hope.

Upward mobility. Foiled again as the government keeps trying to follow Europe's lead and tax anything that moves, literally. They recently proposed putting GPS in automobiles so that they could charge a milage tax and they proposed an extra tax on hybrids because hybrids don't pay enough fuel tax. Gratuitous tipping. No. The government will tax a waitress or waiter on what they think they should make in tips. Anything less than a decent tip is stealing because they will have to pay tax on the income whether they make it or not. All our house servants run on electricity these days. If you want house servants go east, young man, where servants are still servants.
OK so now you move on to India and China...where the growth has been in the making for some time not due to the US patronage.US business interests are in there boots and all because it is an opportunity for corporate pyramids to feed on not because they have any inherent interest in the people their wellbeing or their culture.Never mind the effect on the rest of the world .This is naked self interest and preservation at work.

But only the self interest of a few and not the nation. Of course there are no British, French or German companies in India or China are there?
The rapid industrialisation of these areas is at the expense of health,safety and environmental standards. This does not matter to a well trained credit oblivious consumer in the US because it is somewhere out of mind and the goods are cheap and the profits handsome for the entrepreneur.

You know it is a funny thing but the average Joe in these places is oblivious to the strict standards we set.. As one of my friends translated from the Chinese papers regarding a recent coal mine explosion, "The managers forgot about safety because they were advancing production so fast." If you study the "ancient history" of the US (perhaps 100 years ago) you will see that the people here were treated the same way. Dickens also wrote about conditions in England not so long ago. I am willing to bet that this phase will be much shorter in India and China.
Try telling thousands of hardworking loyal clothing and auto workers how generous you are to make them redundant in favour of someone across the world.Capital maximisation leads to abandonment - it is an antisocial disease refined to extremes in America by people who think the world was made for them to define in their image.So driven is it that management will lie about balance sheets to the max for shareholder and ladder climbing approval.

Until Bush came along with a big stick. Now you go to jail for cooking the books. For some reason Clinton didn't pick up on this.
There are still a few Indians -not the ones who died outright- near a certain chemical works the US doesn't want to know about - how about a trail of unwanted children across the world left from US conflicts- there is a lot of dirt everywhere if you want to turn it over and really look at it with out star spangled good old boy glasses.

An Indian plant run by Indians built with American money and technology. And how many thousands more didn't starve because of the pesticides produced by that plant. Those people who died there are for the most part considered less than dirt by their own countryman. And your hero, Clinton, in a speech to the Bombay stock exchange sent the message that the US wouldn't give a rat's ...ss about how Dalits and Christians were treated. The RSS can teach the glories of Nazism and nobody picks up on it.
Help was offered for New Orleans and was turned down by your President.I suspect there was a good deal of unspoken national guilt and embarrassment that spurred the eventual internal relief efforts.As far as I could tell there is a cultivated resentment of helping your neighbour for any real need mitigated by pointing out afterward in the politest way your personal contribution.

What TV channel were you watching? Mayor Nagin still has not answered why thousands of busses earmarked for evacuation were not used and sat under water. Perhaps the retiring RouteMasters should be deployed to New Orleans with snorkles and raised operating stations. Mayor Nagin is more concerned about Mardi Gras than his own people. While his own people were drowning and pillaging he was trying to get some tourists out of a downtown hotel. The Times Picayune documented over the years how New Orleans residents rejected work on their own dikes and as a consequence lost millions of dollars in federal repair funding. The state militia cannot enter a city unless asked. Mayor Nagin didn't ask. Nor did the governor of Loiusiana. You had police running from their jobs. Pump operators fleeing for their lives. And no, it is not true that Bush can part the waters of lake Pontchartrain.
The US consumes large amounts of the worlds energy per capita and could manage quite well with less and certainly has a responsibility to do something about the 25% of CO2 emissions it makes. Just because US cities got over run with smog and you decided to fix it and you stopped your toxic waste dumping under bushes doesn't mean you have done and can rest pretty now.There are 6 billion of us and we all need to do what we can irrespective of what others can manage.There are people to come after us. Why should they live in our can't be bothered mess?

The US hasn't built a new refinery since the 70s. Ditto for nuclear. While it is true that the US consumption of gasoline is higher than anywhere else the over all picture is that Europe consumes about as much oil as the US and Asia does also. Asian use is accelerating and will soon outstrip the US. US use is centered around gasoline and gasoline is big because autos are used so extensively as transportation. This is not a luxury but a necessity. I get tired of hearing about CO2. It doesn't matter anymore. Methane is the big one now. There is a limit to the greenhouse effect caused by CO2. Once again perspective is needed. And if you look at the trends and the current state of affairs China will soon hold the title of biggest energy consumer. We have a hard time getting steel because of the giant sucking sound to the west. 90% of the world's construction cranes are in China.
The US meddles everywhere 'intelligence' think tanks believe they should and eventually leaves tail down when they rub against reality and the great US dream and American way is exposed for the delusion it is outside the borders.

Guess that applies to Prime Minister Blair as well. I thought he said we were there because it was right. And he is still in office.
Your President walks out when he someone opens the door for him. Give him a helping hand out of Iraq if he can't do it himself.

I think he knows how to time the withdrawal. His dad made the mistake of letting those in southern Iraq think the US would help and then withdrew. Son Bush will not make that mistake again.
There now I will have wound people up.... ;o) till next year... if you still talk to me that is :o)
neil

Next year?? Not long to wait then. :)
 
We haven't had a good roll in the hay like this for some time. It will pass. Nice to know that those who chase the mouse have a life too.
 
No I don't think it will pass.
I can see just how deeply entrenched this type of dreadful thinking is in your society and how problematic and divisive world affairs will be for a time yet because of it. There is a hope abroad that we will get a return to some common sense from the good folk of the US and we keep the door open for that possibility but I am not so confident that will happen next election. Still we don't give up on you yet.Eventually you will overcome your headstrong demons :o) later - next year neil
 
I may disagree with you, Neil, on a few points, but I don't doubt your good intent. I think that people of conscience should examine that selfsame conscience now and again. Or perhaps more often than just now and again. Merry Christmas to you . . . just a couple of days after your summer begins . . . and a good New Year.

'Sporky'
 
If it was obvious Kerry, Kennedy, Pelosi bashing I would have said "neocon BS deleted". I can not tolerate either political extreme.

Found those "WMDs" yet?
 
The US has cleaned up its air and water and land

It had been working a bit at it prior to the neocon & stupidity plague.
 
And then there are China and Brazil. Both have CO plumes visible on satellite imagery. One is burniing down the world's biggest rainforest and the other is burning more coal without pollution devices than any other country. They don't need discussions, they need action.

Which at least China is working rather hard on.
 
The US has a major city destroyed.

http://politicalhumor.about.com/library/images/blbushfishingvacation.htm

"The good news is -- and it's hard for some to see it now -- that out of this chaos is going to come a fantastic Gulf Coast, like it was before. Out of the rubbles of Trent Lott's house -- he's lost his entire house -- there's going to be a fantastic house. And I'm looking forward to sitting on the porch." - G. W. Bush
The people there are taken care of,
albeit a few days late.

Really?
 

Latest threads

Back
Top