MS for house designMS for house design

Status
Not open for further replies.

Bruce Johnston

Usenet Archive
Joined
Jan 15, 2002
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
HELP!
Could someone point me at a basic strategy for using MS in house design?

I'm a forester and a competent amateur carpenter. Our office uses MS for mapping, mostly 2D and I am also reasonably competent around the program in that.

I figured I try doing the basic design and maybe some of the construction drawings for a major reno I'm planning on my house. You know all those great things the computer revolution promised. Change the pitch of your roof with one click, add a dormer, pull one off, tack on a bumpout for a bigger bath.

Yeah, right.

So as a trial run and to get used to working in 3D I started with a simple 10x12 gabled shed. The user's guides and tutorials don't really talk about how to approach such a project so I did it like I would build it. One stick at a time. But since there doesn't seem to be an MS equivalent of a lumber yard I also had to design every 2x4 and sheet of plywood. Acudraw the basic shape, project it as a solid, move it into place.

So yes, trying to draw that nice simple shed in MS probably took me about 3 or 4 times longer that it would have taken me to build it. Changing the siding from board on board to board and batten took a whole weekend in MS. Did a small barn for real in about the same amount of time (with a little help.)

When I started on the house I figured I should begin without all the finicky details. Project a whole roof. Project all four walls at once. Plug in the doors and windows later (sure, how?) Fill in the construction detail after the basic shapes are finished. Sure.

So now I have a featureless box with slanting flaps. I cannot seem to figure out how to punch the windows and doors let alone how to manipulate the slab dimensions to correct a mistake. Like the shed, every change seems to require starting from scratch or at least dropping the element to geometry before the change can be made. At the rate I am going, the real house will have rotted and gone back to earth before I am ready to reno.

About all I have learned for sure (???)
The MODIFY tools that I use all the time in 2D do not do the same with solids. Solids are difficult. I probably should be working with surfaces.

So I ask again, could someone point me at a basic strategy for using MS in house design? Can someone supplement the guides and point out what all those 3D tools are used for and why? Or point me at a reference that will?

Bruce
 
For 3D work I think is preferrable to use MS with Triforma, with which you can punch windows and do all the things you mentioned. Triforma comes included with the "Building Construction" set of Microstation.

Bruce Johnston wrote:
HELP!
Could someone point me at a basic strategy for using MS in house design?

I'm a forester and a competent amateur carpenter. Our office uses MS for mapping, mostly 2D and I am also reasonably competent around the program in that.

I figured I try doing the basic design and maybe some of the construction drawings for a major reno I'm planning on my house. You know all those great things the computer revolution promised. Change the pitch of your roof with one click, add a dormer, pull one off, ...
(..snip...)
 
Bruce,
You can do all of that if you want to , but I would be using the 3D solid tools in MS. Extruding shapes is the old way and pretty fiddly.

There are also special 3D editing tools in the main 3D palette.

If you can it's worth getting something like '3d by examples' as a printed guide.

Otherwise, e-mail me all you want. 3D is my life.
 
Bruce,

Since you are using the term project instead of extrude I am guessing you are using MicroStation 95 or SE. If that is the case the term "solid" only means that the surfaces are capped at both ends instead of open at the ends. even a solid is really just 6 surfaces. True solids modeling is not available in those versions. If that is the case you are really only dealing with surfaces and punching holes in things can be tricky.

My best recommendation is to build the model in wire frame, meaning very simple lines that you will later surface. So instead of placing a wall and punching a hole through it, I would create the basic shape of the wall with lines, including the opening, and then surface model it. Keep the surfaces on seperate levels is a good strategy to insure you can easily turn off the line work later.

If I am wrong here and you are on J the use of the cut solid tool will make your openings. For me, I create a door, then place a shape around the door. I use this shape as the element to cut through the wall.

Shoot me an e-mail if I can help with surface or solid modeling techniques.

Bruce Johnston wrote:
HELP!
Could someone point me at a basic strategy for using MS in house design?

I'm a forester and a competent amateur carpenter. Our office uses MS for mapping, mostly 2D and I am also reasonably competent around the program in that.

I figured I try doing the basic design and maybe some of the construction drawings for a major reno I'm planning on my house. You know all those great things the computer revolution promised. Change the pitch of your roof with one click, add a dormer, pull one off, tack on a bumpout for a bigger bath.
...
 
You might check
http://www.ScienceOxygen.com/design77.html

It does not sell any house design tool there.
But it is with a collection of links about house
design so that you might start from there...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest threads

Back
Top