Important for everybody

Discussion in 'AutoCAD' started by amitvedak, Nov 29, 2004.

  1. amitvedak

    Tom Smith Guest

    Even if it was created off site, off comany time??

    Maybe. Was it the company's copy of AutoCAD? Is the writing these things and
    bringing them in considered part of your job description? Do you have any
    written understanding with the company on this? (Probably not.) Would they
    be in any way surprised if you deleted everything single thing you had
    written when you left the firm. (Probably.)

    I've given the authoritative site reference twice earlier in the thread.
    Read for yourself. Generally, if you're on the payroll, and it's considered
    as part of your job, and you're making use of company "facilities," then
    they own it. If your programming depends on using a company copy of Acad, or
    a company computer, that would probably be viewed as using their
    "facilities" whether you were on site or off.

    If they've been led to believe that all this offsite programming is part of
    the benefit of having you on the payroll, then it may be viewed as part of
    your job description, even if it's your own independent copy of Acad that
    you're using. That wouldn't be quite as clearcut, but it's quite possible
    that you've surrendered your ownership by bringing them in and spreading
    them around as part of your routine, thereby making it seem like part of
    your job.

    The only way to learn the actual "legal" answer is hire lawyers and start
    suing. If you'd prefer to avoid that, then you need to sit down with your
    employer and hash it out. And put it in writing. Soon.

    If you want "your" stuff to really be yours, you need a very clear agreement
    on it. You probably ought to own your own Acad, have a one-man business
    name, and "sell" your stuff to the company (either an outright sale or on a
    license basis). If you aren't contracting this activity with them in a way
    that is clearly separate from your employment, or have a written agreement
    that they'll share the rights with you, it's entirely possible that you've
    already given your programs away.
     
    Tom Smith, Nov 29, 2004
    #21
  2. amitvedak

    Douglas Barr Guest

    those gosh drat lawyers!
     
    Douglas Barr, Nov 29, 2004
    #22
  3. amitvedak

    Walt Engle Guest

    To a degree you are correct. I have lsp routines I wrote as far back as 1986. At that time, they were very, very unusual and I was highly protective of them. However, as time went by, many other people
    began writing similar routines so I now don't consider them "intelectual property" - heck, I give them away now without a second thought.

    But there is another side to this - the company doesn't have the expertise to develope lsp routines or change them when Autodesk changes something in their core.
     
    Walt Engle, Nov 29, 2004
    #23
  4. amitvedak

    Walt Engle Guest

    Copyright laws no long require )c) or copyright notice.
     
    Walt Engle, Nov 29, 2004
    #24
  5. amitvedak

    Tom Smith Guest

    And wouldn't it be somewhat hard to "nail down" what is a copy write
    infringment as far as a lot of the "simple" lisp is concerned?

    Bill, look at http://www.copyright.gov . You can't copyright a concept,
    idea, method, or process. A copyright isn't a patent. You don't have to
    prove originality. Copyright protects "original works of authorship" which
    are "fixed in a tangible form of expression."

    More than one company can copyright a map of the same town, for instance.
    Each of them is protecting only their specific hardcopy map (the tangible
    expression) from being literally duplicated. They aren't protecting anything
    else.

    Things that are utterly mundane (like lists of telephone numbers) or purely
    dictated by function (certain engineering structures) aren't subject to
    copyright protection. If the lisp is that simple, it's probably either not
    fit to be copyrighted, or not worth suing anybody over. If an average jury
    would consider one work to be clearly "derivative" of another (coprighted)
    work, then that would be an infringement.

    The only way things ultimately get "nailed down" is by seeing who wins in
    court. :)












    routines at your company - once
    think so or not. Been there - done
    here to develop) is already out there (maybe slightly different but
    accomplishes the same thing).
    (as I knew nothing about lisping before I got here) so I have no problem
    "giving" them what I've done here.
    because you also need the person behind it that can improvise maintain and
    improve the programs to keep things on the cutting edge.
     
    Tom Smith, Nov 29, 2004
    #25
  6. amitvedak

    BillZ Guest

    But there is another side to this - the company doesn't have the expertise to develope lsp routines or change them when Autodesk changes something in their core.<<

    I was getting at that same thing when I said:

    "I believe also that no written programming will ever carry a company because you also need the person behind it that can improvise maintain and improve the programs to keep things on the cutting edge."

    :)

    I would say "job security" but I hate that term.

    My supervisors have also said that they hate to see the companies success rest entirely on what I've done here.
    They seem to think that if something happens to me or I retire someday, they won't be able to fill my shoes.
    It's hard to believe, now that I look back, that I had so much trouble convincing them that this was the way to go in the first place.
    Again, it's the man behind the code that makes it work.

    Bill

    Bill
     
    BillZ, Nov 29, 2004
    #26
  7. amitvedak

    ECCAD Guest

    I know that, but it is still good practice I would think.

    Bye the way (since I AM the company), anything I write
    is OK for the 'company' to have rights to. :))

    Bob
     
    ECCAD, Nov 29, 2004
    #27
  8. Hi Amit,

    Most of the discussion has been around your rights to do this. The primary
    answer to your first question, 'Is it legal to sell you programs? Of course
    it is.

    Accepting that you have all the rights you need (and it's quite possible you
    are not USA based and therefore subject to different and less company
    orientated copyright rules), then you have to work on the marketing of your
    program.

    Search the web for lisp and other programs which enhance AutoCAD, and it is
    quite possible you will find freeware which does similar things to your
    program. You need to be sure that your program is adequately different from
    these other programs such that users will want to buy it.

    How can you establish a reputation such that potential purchasers will think
    "Amit" has the solution for me?

    How can a user feel confident that you will be in business next year to
    provide support for the program?

    Can you continue to eat if sales remain low?

    How can you demonstrate what the program does?

    Do you need help files?

    How an you ensure you get paid?

    What is your refund policy?

    How do you secure the program?

    How do you quality check it? Is it operating system sensitive?

    Which versions of AutoCAD does it run on?

    Do you update for new AutoCAD version? Free?

    I suspect you will find the marketing issues far more significant than the
    technical ones.

    --


    Laurie Comerford
    CADApps
    www.cadapps.com.au


    lisp and menus. Compatible with acad 2000/4/5.
     
    Laurie Comerford, Nov 29, 2004
    #28
  9. amitvedak

    John Uhden Guest

    Hmm. That *is* a while ago, even prior to the Battle of Hastings!
     
    John Uhden, Nov 30, 2004
    #29
  10. amitvedak

    amitvedak Guest

    Many many Thanks Laurie &
    also thanks to all who replied me,

    laurie your reply is really useful for me.
    i noted your all points. i am trying to take care of all of them.

    well,
    my software is almost completed now. and i can say its a fastet piping isometric drafting software in the world.
    i customised it very deep after my 11 years as piping designer and cad experience.
    hope peoples will like it.

    most important point is lock of software. its just difficult to lock a software with perticular computer, coz many ways are there to break.
    as my experience. i also tried to break lot of codes. personally i can lock the my lsp prog. with pericular computer by disk serial no. but i cant reach to my each clients. also it will not work if formated the harddisk.
    even registri entries can be also hacked.
    lets see what happends..

    actually I tried registry in 4 to locations combine + text log files on harddisk as my software lock.

    But still I feel it if not good. [may be 5 peoples in 100 can break my codes].

    Pls advice me best locking procedure. Hardware part or software lock
    also advice if any marketing site for lisp programs.

    regards,
    Amit
     
    amitvedak, Dec 1, 2004
    #30
  11. amitvedak

    amitvedak Guest

    thanks jan,
    i'm really very happy. after reading ur reply
    u are the 1st person who replied me. and its in positive way.

    thanks again
    Amit
     
    amitvedak, Dec 1, 2004
    #31
  12. amitvedak

    James Allen Guest

    Attn: Anne,

    Hi again, here is another one. At work (nttp) I see nothing nested under
    the following quoted post, but I know there is because I see it on the web
    and at home (also nttp).

    <feeling pest-like>
     
    James Allen, Dec 1, 2004
    #32
  13. amitvedak

    Anne Brown Guest

    James -

    It has to be something on your work set up. Can you delete nntp
    there and reinstall?

    The web team has not found anything amiss with the three
    structure and I've seen no other reports like yours. I truly wish
    I could do more.

    Not pest like - just wanting your messages!

    Anne
     
    Anne Brown, Dec 1, 2004
    #33
  14. amitvedak

    Anne Brown Guest

    typo - three is supposed to be tree.

    Anne
     
    Anne Brown, Dec 2, 2004
    #34
  15. amitvedak

    Doug Broad Guest

    Anne,
    We juth thought you were lithping with uth. ;-)
    Regards,
    Doug
     
    Doug Broad, Dec 2, 2004
    #35
  16. amitvedak

    James Allen Guest

    Thank you Anne. I will try that. But it will be at home and work (remember
    I see the same problem both places). By "delete nntp" do you just mean
    un/re install OE and Outlook, or is there something more to it, or totally
    different...?

    In the meantime, is it possible that this post is related? -

    Anne wrote >"Not pest like - just wanting your messages!"

    Well, yeah, but more concerned that it's not just me. Switching back and
    forth between home and work, I figure I'm probably catching most if not all
    of them. But if I were on either one alone I certainly would not be.

    Thank you,

    James
     
    James Allen, Dec 2, 2004
    #36
  17. amitvedak

    Anne Brown Guest

    James -

    here are saved messages from others who have lost threads in the
    past. I do not use OE so point you to Microsoft groups if you
    need more info.

    Anne
    ---
    Anne Brown
    Discussion Groups Administrator
    Autodesk, Inc.

    MISSING MESSAGES

    In Outlook Express, if you want to get all the headers in one
    shot, rmb on
    the group, and go to Properties >> Local Files Tab >> Reset.
    That will
    remove everything from the group. Then RMB on the group and go
    to
    Synchronization Settings >> Headers Only.

    Finally without going into the group by left clicking during all
    this, go to
    Tools >> Synchronize All. Allow it to run and it should get all
    the
    headers in one shot.

    ----
    Microsoft Outlook Express 6
    (http://support.microsoft.com/default.aspx?scid=kb;EN-US;171164)

    Go to tools/options/maintenance and uncheck delete news messages
    x days
    after being downloaded. You will then retain all messages.
    Right click on
    the discussion.autodesk.com and choose reset groups. Redownload
    the
    messages.

    or

    Menu item "View"MISSING , "Current View" choose "Show all
    messages"

    Also choose "Tools" - "Options" -"maintenance" and unclick
    "Delete read
    message bodies in newsgroups" and "Delete messages older than
    ____ days"

    or
    more information may be found at msnews.microsoft.com
    /microsoft.public.windows.inetexplorer.ie6_outlookexpress or at
    "Inside Outlook Express" at http://insideoe.tomsterdam.com/
     
    Anne Brown, Dec 2, 2004
    #37
  18. amitvedak

    Anne Brown Guest

    Forgot to say I've also asked the server admin folk to take a
    look and be sure the NNTP and HTTP sides of the server are in
    synch.
     
    Anne Brown, Dec 2, 2004
    #38
  19. amitvedak

    amitvedak Guest

    Hi Bob,

    thanks for your advice.
    if not mistaken u are also a seller of autolisp programs.
    i think i've seen eccad site.
    can u advice me code for protect my program to avoid piracy?
    pls. reply

    regards
    Amit
     
    amitvedak, Dec 3, 2004
    #39
  20. amitvedak

    Gary D'Arcy Guest

    Nice one I Admit.

    I thought you whee Alex J. I loved that guy.

    Anyway welcome back after sometime off keep em guessing but
    I think I am closing in!

    Regards Gary
     
    Gary D'Arcy, Dec 3, 2004
    #40
Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.