"DougW" wrote:
In the words of the late great Alex Januszkiewicz, God rest his soul:
[snip of a pretty good restating of much of what we have been discussing]
"To have smooth translation (assuming V8 works as promised), somebody will have to stick to lines, circles, 3D solids and other basic objects common to all cadd systems, and stay away from anything that unleashes the real power of today's AutoCAD: ARX applications with their custom objects."
Alex was a valuble resource in this industry as well as an excellent ranter on this NG and CCA. He passed away suddenly a few weeks ago and will be sorely missed. But aren't his words here quite true?
For the most part, yes; but I will take issue with one part: the real power of today's AutoCAD is its ubiquity. There is nothing exceptional in ARX applications, or "custom objects." What is exceptional about the base product is the number of people using it. The vast majority of AutoCAD users don't use much if anything more than the basic, common CAD elements, and most don't use anything but 2D.
While the real potential power of AutoCAD-based ARX applications lies in objects embedded within DWG files (or some other datastore -- DWG in and of itself isn't that important technically), this is only inert potential until end users actually deploy and make use of them.
Effectively, Autodesk is trying to coax basic, common DWG users into using other proprietary products whose data is normally embedded in a mostly inaccessible way within DWG files. By blurring the distinction between traditional DWG, DWG as used, and DWG with embedded objects, Autodesk seeks to transition much of their userbase over to using these new proprietary products without those users too critically examining the merits of this transition or of alternative strategies and products.
How effective Autodesk is, or will be, in persuading users into this transition is, therefore, the first question to ask when thinking about whether non-Autodesk products can make effective use of DWG files. At least for now it mostly doesn't matter that V8 or similar products can't make full use of embedded DWG object data: AutoCAD users mostly don't use such objects either.
Mark