A2K to SDRC, ProE, STEP, or Solidworks

Status
Not open for further replies.

Mark Licata

Usenet Archive
Joined
Nov 28, 2001
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
My client used Acad2000 to design a plastic component, but some of my vendors will not quote the job without a ProE, Solidworks, IGES solid or STEP model. The client has given me the file in DWG, DXF, and STL format.

I have access to SDRC IDEAS, SolidView, IntelliCAD, AutoCAD LT 98, and formZ, but attempts to import the STL and make an iges file result in wireframe models that will not "solidify" in SDRC. When I view the drawing it only looks good in paperspace, in model space it appears to be a series of overlapping 2d drawings in each plane.

Is it possible there is a solid model in the database I can't see with IntelliCAD? I had my client export to a R14 DWG file so I could look at it in AutoCAD LT 98 but it looked the same as the IntelliCAD view of the A2K DWG file. Does A2K construct a STL file w/o a solid model?

Any help is appreciated.
 
comp.cad.autocad, Mark Licata wrote:
My client used Acad2000 to design a plastic component, but some of my vendors will not quote the job without a ProE, Solidworks, IGES solid or STEP model. The client has given me the file in DWG, DXF, and STL format.

Have you tried import/export usingRhino3D from McNeel?
It has a reputation as a very robust and fault tolerant modeler that integrates well between different applications, including Autocad.
 
On Wed, 28 Nov 2001 18:27:18 -0500, Jim Patrick
wrote:

Have you tried import/export usingRhino3D from McNeel?

www.mcneel.com. And they have a free trial version, fully functional, available for download. It allows 25 saves, the only restriction on its use. Otherwise it's fully functional.
 
Jim Patrick wrote:
Have you tried import/export usingRhino3D from McNeel?

Thanks but no cigar. Both A2K and R14 DWG files come up as 2D drawings. Shading or rendering results in a blank screen. Rhino can import the STL OK, but exporting to SDRC, IGES, or Step results in "polygon surfaces" that can't be exported. Now I'm down to 21 saves. I may go ahead and buy the Rhino though - it looks like a pretty good product.

Note: I was wrong about AcadLT97: the r14 DWG file opens as a model with surfaces I can shade. So at least now I can see my client is telling the truth.

Should I find someone with Mechanical Desktop or Inventor to export a valid model? Are there any other options?
 
Mark,

I believe you are going to have trouble in getting what you need from the file you received. It is likely that it is not a true solid model. Your best bet is to get someone to generate a tree solid model in either Mechanical Desktop, Inventor, Solidworks or Ideas. Actually, your previous post stated that you have access to Ideas. Why not just spend a few hours (assuming it is not a very complex model) and generate the model in Ideas yourself? Otherwise, any one of the other programs should give you what you want for your vendors. I have experience in most of them and the output is easy once the model is created.

Mike

On Fri, 30 Nov 2001 11:25:00 -0500, Mark Licata
wrote:

Jim Patrick wrote:
>
> Have you tried import/export usingRhino3D from McNeel?

Thanks but no cigar. Both A2K and R14 DWG files come up as 2D drawings. Shading or rendering results in a blank screen. Rhino can import the STL OK, but exporting to SDRC, IGES, or Step results in "polygon surfaces" that can't be exported. Now I'm down to 21 saves. I may go ahead and buy the Rhino though - it looks like a pretty good product.

Note: I was wrong about AcadLT97: the r14 DWG file opens as a model with surfaces I can shade. So at least now I can see my client is telling ...
 
comp.cad.autocad, Mark Licata wrote:
[re: Rhino]
Thanks but no cigar. Both A2K and R14 DWG files come up as 2D drawings. Shading or rendering results in a blank screen.

Then they *are* 2D drawings with no solids in them. Sounds like the client has more than one file on this or just wblocked some of it out.

.....Rhino can import the STL
OK, but exporting to SDRC, IGES, or Step results in "polygon surfaces" that can't be exported. Now I'm down to 21 saves. I may go ahead and buy the Rhino though - it looks like a pretty good product.

Note: I was wrong about AcadLT97: the r14 DWG file opens as a model with surfaces I can shade. So at least now I can see my client is telling the truth.

Should I find someone with Mechanical Desktop or Inventor to export a valid model?

If you know someone that can do it, yes.

....Are there any other options?

One other option is to send the 'model' file back to the creator and ask where he gets a solid from it. Can he export the solid? An export to ACIS (acisout) is a better option from Autocad.

BTW, how big is the file?
 
"(whodat?)" wrote:
Why not just spend a few hours (assuming it is not a very complex model) and generate the model in Ideas yourself?

There will be more iterations and the designer wants to keep "control" of the model in A2K, so any model I generate in Ideas will be wasted. I'm really just streamlining the process A2K --> Injection mold. Besides, the client is always right - he says he has a solid model and sends me valid STL files that sure look solid.

I did a little more research on the Rhino news archive and it turns out that Rhino does not import ACAD solids. I guess the DWG format allows for a combination of 2D and solid data, and Rhino only sees the 2D data. The Rhino moderator suggested a 3DS export from A2K that makes "meshes" that Rhino can see and stitch back together into a solid.

Thanks for your suggestion.
 
Mark,

OK, I understand. Well, assuming he is using the primitive solids available in standard A2K, the following seems to work. Have him generate an ACIS file (.sat) from the solid. Import that ACIS file into a true solid modeler. I tried it in Solidworks using the function called Featureworks that will generate a true parametric solid model. At that point, Solidworks was able to generate a good STEP file that had information that other modelers could read (including Ideas). I tried it with a simple boolean construct in plain A2K and it worked.

Mike

On Fri, 30 Nov 2001 16:39:37 -0500, Mark Licata
wrote:

"(whodat?)" wrote:
>
> Why not just spend a few hours (assuming it is not a very complex
> model) and generate the model in Ideas yourself?

There will be more iterations and the designer wants to keep "control" of the model in A2K, so any model I generate in Ideas will be wasted. I'm really just streamlining the process A2K --> Injection mold. Besides, the client is always right - he says he has a solid model and sends me valid STL files that sure look solid.

I did a little more research on the Rhino news archive and it turns out ...
 
Jim Patrick wrote:
One other option is to send the 'model' file back to the creator and ask where he gets a solid from it. Can he export the solid? An export to ACIS (acisout) is a better option from Autocad.

I'll ask him to do it next time. I played with the R14 dwg file in AcadLT and was able to strip away all the 2D sections and dimensions. That reduced the file size from 4.6 to 2.6 MB. I was then able to import the model into formZ, which recognized it as an ACIS solid. A formZ IGES export was then recognized as a solid by Rhino. Now I have a STEP export from Rhino to send to my vendors.

So my problem was that the ACIS model was mixed in with a bunch of 2D data which messed with my import filters. Also, I wasted too much time trying to convert the STL file into a IGES or STEP solid. I won't make that mistake again.

Thanks for your help.
 
No Doubt About It! For contract designers/engineers like you and myself, file conversions between different packages and formats can be one of the biggest hassles.

Mike

On Mon, 03 Dec 2001 10:19:09 -0500, Mark Licata
wrote:

Jim Patrick wrote:
>
> One other option is to send the 'model' file back to the creator and
> ask where he gets a solid from it. Can he export the solid?
> An export to ACIS (acisout) is a better option from Autocad.

I'll ask him to do it next time. I played with the R14 dwg file in AcadLT and was able to strip away all the 2D sections and dimensions. That reduced the file size from 4.6 to 2.6 MB. I was then able to import the model into formZ, which recognized it as an ACIS solid. A formZ IGES export was then recognized as a solid by Rhino. Now I have a STEP export from Rhino to send to my vendors.
...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest threads

Back
Top