a challenging feature...any help?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Jon Fawcett

Usenet Archive
Joined
Jun 21, 2000
Messages
492
Reaction score
0
I'm creating a baseball and am trying to make the stitches based on curves.
Here's the problem.

I projected a curve onto the sphere to represent the seam that runs around the whole ball. But creating the cross stitches that run perpendicular to this curve is proving a bit of a challenge.

Here's what I've tried:
creating a datum point, which could later be patterned and then use a reference pattern to get all the features attached to it that define the cross stitch. problem with this is that i can only figure out how to make the sketching plane and reference plane by creating a tan curve axis and a point on surf axis through the point. these easily define the sketching plane and ref plane, but they won't ref pattern with the point.

creating the point, and projecting a curve that is dimensioned to only it. problem is, when ref. patterning, the projected curve will not change angles to be perpendicular to the seam because the point has no x-y orientation, so again, i'm back to the orientation of the axis that were created that can't be ref patterned.

i do realize that i could pattern the point and create all the axis for my sketching planes and all features after those independently, but we're talking about several hundred features to get this done this way.

any ideas?

if i can't figure it out, i may go into isdx and just create all the curves on surface by hand, which would be close enough for my visual purposes for this model, but if anyone has another idea i'd love to try it.

-jon
 
Jon,

Greetings again. Your onto the solution with the pattern of points. I believe the key here is to create the sketching plane "on the fly" "thru" the first point, "normal to the curve" to get the first point as the driving feature of the pattern. Don't worry about the orientation of the sketching plane, I think the software will take care of it. Pattern the points first. Use a sweep or swept blend for the "lace", a diameter will work and bury it into the sphere at the first point. Pattern the "lace" as a reference and it should go.

I created a point "on curve, actual length" as the attribute and it worked. Since you need the curves to be around the baseball you may need to use a couple discrete curves but the representation should work fine.

Let me know how it goes.

Dean

On Mon, 17 Dec 2001 18:32:29 GMT, "Jon Fawcett"
wrote:

I'm creating a baseball and am trying to make the stitches based on curves.
Here's the problem.

I projected a curve onto the sphere to represent the seam that runs around the whole ball. But creating the cross stitches that run perpendicular to this curve is proving a bit of a challenge.

Here's what I've tried:
creating a datum point, which could later be patterned and then use a reference pattern to get all the features attached to it that define the cross stitch. problem with this is that i can only figure out how to make the sketching plane and reference plane by creating a tan curve axis and a ...
 
Jon,

Well it doesn't sound like much fun but I would suggest a few things.

First, a reminder, only focus on one quarter of the ball and mirror the finished quarter and then the half.

I would establish another parallel rail/curve line from the main stitch curve and a line from the center of the ball to the main curve and a perpendicular line to the parallel curve to establish the plane which will then be perpendicular to the main curve. Then setup the construction for the two stitches which will be patterned along the main curve.

Yeh, easy for me to say. 8^)

..

Jon Fawcett wrote:
I'm creating a baseball and am trying to make the stitches based on curves.
Here's the problem.

I projected a curve onto the sphere to represent the seam that runs around the whole ball. But creating the cross stitches that run perpendicular to this curve is proving a bit of a challenge.

Here's what I've tried:
creating a datum point, which could later be patterned and then use a reference pattern to get all the features attached to it that define the cross stitch. problem with this is that i can only figure out how to make the sketching plane and reference plane by creating a tan curve axis and a ...
 
Dean,

This is the way I originally tried it. But the problem is that Pro can't figure out a default for the sketching reference plane. that's where I couldn't figure out a way to create the plane on the fly and tried creating the axis/pnt thru surf that couldn't be ref patterned. the line below is where the entire thing comes to a screaching halt.

I figured it out though. Here's what I did...in case anyone has a use for this sometime.

1. create the first curve projected onto the sphere which represents the main seam.
2. create another projected curve that is offset from the first. i used
0.100. it is easiest if you create a sketched curve first and then use that as the reference for both curves.
3. create a point on both curves as a length ratio. the offset curve will effect the length ratio. The closer they are, the less it effects it. I chose to tweak the number for the 2nd point till they looked close.
4. create the projected curve for the stitch. you have to make plane through the first point, normal to the first curve. then use the 'setup new' functionality in the menu to create another plane that goes through both points and normal to the first plane. This will be the sketching plane. for the reference plane, select the first plane created.

for the pattern, you can pattern both points in the same pattern and use that as the basis for the reference pattern.

this worked out close enough for visual purposes.

-Jon

Don't worry about the
orientation of the sketching plane, I think the software will take care of it.
 
Paul,

great suggestion! I posted the way I figured it out before your post came through, but adding a curve that connects between the center of the sphere out to the point that will be patterned should provide the direction needed for the reference plane. this will create an entity exactly the same direction as the axis 'point on surface' that it wouldn't let me ref. pattern. I'll have to try this way and see if it will allow me to ref.
pattern this new curve.

I actually think you can do it this way with only the main seam curve, a point on this curve, and a curve attaching this point to the center of the sphere. the 2 other curves, i believe, would be unneeded because the datums can be made on the fly with these 3 entities.

btw, your way should be 100% accurate if it let's me pattern it, where as my way was visually accurate only. geometry is off slightly.

thanks.

Jon

"Paul Salvador" wrote:

Jon,

Well it doesn't sound like much fun but I would suggest a few things.

First, a reminder, only focus on one quarter of the ball and mirror the finished quarter and then the half.

I would establish another parallel rail/curve line from the main stitch curve and a line from the center of the ball to the main curve and a perpendicular line to the parallel curve to establish the plane which will then be perpendicular to the main curve. Then setup the construction for the two stitches which will be patterned along the main ...
curves.
> Here's the problem.
>
> I projected a curve onto the sphere to represent the seam that runs
around
> the whole ball. But creating the cross stitches that run perpendicular
to
> this curve is proving a bit of a challenge.
>
> Here's what I've tried:
> creating a datum point, which could later be patterned and then use a
> reference pattern to get all the features attached to it that define the
> cross stitch. problem with this is that i can only figure out how to
make
> the sketching plane and reference plane by creating a tan curve axis and
a
> point on surf axis through the point. these easily define the sketching
> plane and ref plane, but they won't ref pattern with the point.
>
> creating the point, and projecting a curve that is dimensioned to only
it.
> problem is, when ref. patterning, the projected curve will not change
angles
> to be perpendicular to the seam because the point has no x-y
orientation, so
> again, i'm back to the orientation of the axis that were created that
can't
> be ref patterned.
>
> i do realize that i could pattern the point and create all the axis for
my
> sketching planes and all features after those independently, but we're
> talking about several hundred features to get this done this way.
>
> any ideas?
>
> if i can't figure it out, i may go into isdx and just create all the
curves
> on surface by hand, which would be close enough for my visual purposes
for
> this model, but if anyone has another idea i'd love to try it.
>
> -jon
 
I am sure you tried this, but isn't there a constrain to keep the stitch perpendicular to the seam, so when pattering it should remain perpendicular?

Tom

"Jon Fawcett" schrieb im Newsbeitrag

I'm creating a baseball and am trying to make the stitches based on
curves.
Here's the problem.

I projected a curve onto the sphere to represent the seam that runs around the whole ball. But creating the cross stitches that run perpendicular to this curve is proving a bit of a challenge.

Here's what I've tried:
creating a datum point, which could later be patterned and then use a reference pattern to get all the features attached to it that define the cross stitch. problem with this is that i can only figure out how to make the sketching plane and reference plane by creating a tan curve axis and a point on surf axis through the point. these easily define the sketching ...
angles
to be perpendicular to the seam because the point has no x-y orientation,
so
again, i'm back to the orientation of the axis that were created that
can't
be ref patterned.

i do realize that i could pattern the point and create all the axis for my sketching planes and all features after those independently, but we're talking about several hundred features to get this done this way.

any ideas?

if i can't figure it out, i may go into isdx and just create all the
curves
on surface by hand, which would be close enough for my visual purposes for this model, but if anyone has another idea i'd love to try it.

-jon
 
That's correct, but it still leaves the problem of getting into the sketch. Because the sketching plane is on a very screwed up angle, Pro/E won't find a default reference plane to define the orientation of the sketch.

Thanks everyone for your help. I'd be glad to hear more ideas if you have them, even though I've got it working...never know when they'll be a better way.

-Jon

"Dammerl" wrote:

I am sure you tried this, but isn't there a constrain to keep the stitch perpendicular to the seam, so when pattering it should remain
perpendicular?
Tom

"Jon Fawcett" schrieb im Newsbeitrag

> I'm creating a baseball and am trying to make the stitches based on curves.
> Here's the problem.
>
> I projected a curve onto the sphere to represent the seam that runs
around
> the whole ball. But creating the cross stitches that run perpendicular
to
> this curve is proving a bit of a challenge.
>
> Here's what I've tried:
> creating a datum point, which could later be patterned and then use a
> reference pattern to get all the features attached to it that define the
> cross stitch. problem with this is that i can only figure out how to
make
> the sketching plane and reference plane by creating a tan curve axis and
a
> point on surf axis through the point. these easily define the sketching
> plane and ref plane, but they won't ref pattern with the point.
>
> creating the point, and projecting a curve that is dimensioned to only
it.
> problem is, when ref. patterning, the projected curve will not change angles
> to be perpendicular to the seam because the point has no x-y
orientation,
so
> again, i'm back to the orientation of the axis that were created that can't
> be ref patterned.
>
> i do realize that i could pattern the point and create all the axis for
my
> sketching planes and all features after those independently, but we're
> talking about several hundred features to get this done this way.
>
> any ideas?
>
> if i can't figure it out, i may go into isdx and just create all the curves
> on surface by hand, which would be close enough for my visual purposes
for
> this model, but if anyone has another idea i'd love to try it.
>
> -jon
>
>
 
Craig emailed me something I hadn't thought of. Pattern it as a group. this worked perfectly. I grouped the length ratio point, the curve connected from that point to the sphere center, and the protrusion.

I typically don't use groups because they are a pain to deal with during major changes to features contained within the group. ie adding/deleting features from it. But in this case, I think it might be the only to get it to pattern.

Anyone interested in seeing the model, can download it from www.fawcett.com/baseball.zip All features are suppressed.

-Jon

"Jon Fawcett" wrote:

Attached is a jpeg of the final baseball. Turned out pretty good with the following method:

1. create 1/4 of sphere
2. create projected curve for the main seam.
3. create point with length ratio on the curve
4. create point at center of sphere
5. create curve thru points. center of sphere to point on seam
6. create protrusion for first stitch. creating 2 planes on the fly. one
is
through the seam point and normal to the seam curve. the other is through the curve that connects to the sphere center and normal to the first
created
plane. you have to create the reference plane first, then create a new
plane
for the sketching plane, then go back and select the first plan for the reference.

it wouldn't pattern this protrusion and i couldn't figure out why, so i ended up creating all the stitch protrusions. only about 20, so it wasn't that big of a deal.

7. added rounds to the stitches
8. swept a protrusion on the seam curve
9. mirrored both ways to complete the ball.

If anyone wants to give it a show to figure out why the stitch protrusion ...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest threads

Back
Top