3D CAD Software comparison

Status
Not open for further replies.

Dominic Brunelle

Usenet Archive
Joined
Dec 17, 2001
Messages
15
Reaction score
0
Hi,

I'm looking for a comparison chart (or something like that) of all the 3D cad software in the middle range category, like solidedge, solidworks, ... They are almost all the same and I was hoping to see a independant judgment prior to choosing the "right" one. Any suggestions?

Thanks. (Sorry if I made a cross-post)
 
(Dominic Brunelle) wrote:
Hi,

I'm looking for a comparison chart (or something like that) of all the 3D cad software in the middle range category, like solidedge, solidworks, ... They are almost all the same and I was hoping to see a independant judgment prior to choosing the "right" one. Any suggestions?

Thanks. (Sorry if I made a cross-post)

There have been some long multi-dozen post messages in prior postings you can search here with the back button "Next 25 Threads" that talk of AutoDesk vs Solidworks and ProE vs Solidworks.

Then some of those messages refer to articles in Desktop Engineering and elsewhere which compare and detail differences between packages.

Generally, the fast rising sales and market share of SolidWorks has a lot of other CAD companies on edge. The ease of learning (I never did take a class; just watched the online demo, CD, tutorial, and started my own parts), and integration with accessory add-in programs is consistent and easily very productive for the SWks Office and the other items I've picked up. SDRC's Ideas and Vellum, which I tried before SWks, just weren't right for me, and I should have figured a way to try them out with some form of 30 day demo-timed use. I would have saved a bunch of $s.

I would rather see you go to your local SWks dealer, and all others you want to consider, see a demo, then ask to be able to interview one of their customers who use their software for your type of tasks. Pick the best 2 and try them out for 30 days and see how your jobs stack up.

It is too damned easy for an experienced 3D solids salesman to show you only the "Good Stuff", and bypass other things. Outside users and your own trials will give you far better idea for your particular type of use.

Bo
 
Go to www.midrangecad.com

(Dominic Brunelle) wrote:
Hi,

I'm looking for a comparison chart (or something like that) of all the 3D cad software in the middle range category, like solidedge, solidworks, ... They are almost all the same and I was hoping to see a independant judgment prior to choosing the "right" one. Any suggestions?

Thanks. (Sorry if I made a cross-post)
 
My personal choice would be Designcad 3D Max. Here is a link that may be helpful. http://www.stlwork.com/3dcad.html

(Dominic Brunelle) wrote:
Hi,

I'm looking for a comparison chart (or something like that) of all the 3D cad software in the middle range category, like solidedge, solidworks, ... They are almost all the same and I was hoping to see a independant judgment prior to choosing the "right" one. Any suggestions?

Thanks. (Sorry if I made a cross-post)
 
This may be a helpful link. http://www.stlwork.com/3dcad.html

(Dominic Brunelle) wrote:
Hi,

I'm looking for a comparison chart (or something like that) of all the 3D cad software in the middle range category, like solidedge, solidworks, ... They are almost all the same and I was hoping to see a independant judgment prior to choosing the "right" one. Any suggestions?

Thanks. (Sorry if I made a cross-post)
 
Desktop Engineering magazine has had a whole slew of mid-range comparisons done by Joe Greco. The articles (in a series) are all named "MCAD Up Close". They were in the March, May, August, September and December 2000 issues and the March, July and October 2001 issues. Generally, SolidWorks ended up at or near the top with just about everything. I'm not sure the full text is on the Web site, but at least some is, and a chart (in PDF format) showing the capabilities of each. Probably worth printing out, now that I think of it. He wasn't 100% accurate all the time, but for someone trying to work 7 or 8 CAD packages at once he didn't do too badly.

www.deskeng.com

'Sporky'

Dominic Brunelle wrote:
Hi,

I'm looking for a comparison chart (or something like that) of all the 3D cad software in the middle range category, like solidedge, solidworks, ... They are almost all the same and I was hoping to see a independant judgment prior to choosing the "right" one. Any suggestions?

Thanks. (Sorry if I made a cross-post)
 
(Dominic Brunelle) writes:

Hi,

I'm looking for a comparison chart (or something like that) of all the 3D cad software in the middle range category, like solidedge, solidworks, ... They are almost all the same and I was hoping to see a independant judgment prior to choosing the "right" one. Any suggestions?

Thanks. (Sorry if I made a cross-post)

Yes you made a cross-post (which I am also doing to let people know), including a group that has nothing to do with 3D CAD or AutoCAD or anything like that. Comp.cad.synthesis is for electronic microchip design software. I wish you, and all the other clueless people who post this junk to this group and comp.cad.cadence, would take the time to figure what groups they are posting to.

David
 
Take a pill, he did appologize in advance for his cross post. He is asking a real question, not posting porn links or other garbage.

"David Rogoff" wrote:

(Dominic Brunelle) writes:

> Hi,
>
> I'm looking for a comparison chart (or something like that) of all
> the 3D cad software in the middle range category, like solidedge,
> solidworks, ... They are almost all the same and I was hoping to see
> a independant judgment prior to choosing the "right" one. Any
> suggestions?
>
> Thanks. (Sorry if I made a cross-post)

...
 
Learn to read. The problem wasn't the cross-post. It was the post to an inappropriate group.

"hdd" writes:
Take a pill, he did appologize in advance for his cross post. He is asking a real question, not posting porn links or other garbage.

"David Rogoff" wrote:

> (Dominic Brunelle) writes:
>
> > Hi,
> >
> > I'm looking for a comparison chart (or something like that) of all
> > the 3D cad software in the middle range category, like solidedge,
> > solidworks, ... They are almost all the same and I was hoping to see ...
 
Desktop Engineering magazine has had a whole slew of mid-range comparisons done by Joe Greco. The articles (in a series) are all named "MCAD Up Close". They were in the March, May, August, September and December 2000 issues and the March, July and October 2001 issues. Generally, SolidWorks ended up at or near the top with just about everything. I'm not sure the full text is on the Web site, but at least some is, and a chart (in PDF format) showing the capabilities of each. Probably worth printing out, now that I think of it. He wasn't 100% accurate all the time, but for someone trying to work 7 or 8 CAD packages at once he didn't do too badly.

www.deskeng.com

'Sporky'

Dominic Brunelle wrote:
Hi,

I'm looking for a comparison chart (or something like that) of all the 3D cad software in the middle range category, like solidedge, solidworks, ... They are almost all the same and I was hoping to see a independant judgment prior to choosing the "right" one. Any suggestions?

Thanks. (Sorry if I made a cross-post)
 
(Dominic Brunelle) wrote:
Hi,

I'm looking for a comparison chart (or something like that) of all the 3D cad software in the middle range category, like solidedge, solidworks, ... They are almost all the same and I was hoping to see a independant judgment prior to choosing the "right" one. Any suggestions?

Thanks. (Sorry if I made a cross-post)

I have a comparison of the midrange packages posted at
www.midrangecad.com. 3D-Don has already plugged the site once.

Jim Smithie, Webmaster
www.midrangecad.com
 
Get off your high horse. You are just as guilty by posting shit*y rants on the group. At least he had a genuine point!!!!
Ever thought of Prozac???????

"David Rogoff" wrote:

Learn to read. The problem wasn't the cross-post. It was the post to an inappropriate group.

"hdd" writes:
> Take a pill, he did appologize in advance for his cross post. He is
asking a
> real question, not posting porn links or other garbage.
>
> "David Rogoff" wrote:
>
> > (Dominic Brunelle) writes:
> >
> > > Hi,
> > >
> > > I'm looking for a comparison chart (or something like that) of
all
> > > the 3D cad software in the middle range category, like solidedge,
> > > solidworks, ... They are almost all the same and I was hoping to
see
> > > a independant judgment prior to choosing the "right" one. Any
> > > suggestions?
> > >
> > > Thanks. (Sorry if I made a cross-post)
> >
> > Yes you made a cross-post (which I am also doing to let people know),
> > including a group that has nothing to do with 3D CAD or AutoCAD or
> > anything like that. Comp.cad.synthesis is for electronic microchip
> > design software. I wish you, and all the other clueless people who
> > post this junk to this group and comp.cad.cadence, would take the time
> > to figure what groups they are posting to.
> >
...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest threads

Back
Top